Some errors are better

It has been quite a long time since I had some spare time to work on my still-not-working SD card interface for the Apple II.

After rewriting almost all of the VHDL code for the card's CPLD it still would not boot and most of the time crashed with a more ore less garbled message of "Unable to load ProDOS". The fact that this message is shown at all means that at least the first block of the volume is loaded and executed. But the messed up message indicates an issue in the transmission either from card to CPLD or from CPLD to the computer. I checked the data coming from the card and it seems fine.
Thanks to Protek over at the Applefritter forum, I found a step into the right direction. He built a card from my design and uses a quite old version of my sources, that was sort of working. He swapped the 74HCT type bus transceiver for a 74LS type and instantly got better results.

I tried the same and got better results, too. Well sort of. The "Unable to load ProDOS" message is now stable. But hey, it's an improvement! I don't understand why, but there seem to be some subtle timing differences between HCT and LS that I missed. Strangely, in one of the TechNotes for the GS, Apple suggest to use either HCT or LS types. 

Maybe I should call a colleague from a previous job, I'm sure he has an explanation for that. He really knows about electronic design and used to work for IBM in the 80s. One of his designs was a Video-Overlay card that was used to display Btx on the original PC and XT. Btx was an (overpriced) online service in Germany prior to the internet.

The fact that the error message is now stable means that I can focus on the real cause. I think there may be something wrong with the block addressing, but I can't put my finger on it right now. It sounds weird, but some errors are "better" than others.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How to prepare SD cards for the AppleIISd

Image
Here is how to prepare SD cards for use with my AppleIISd. Please be aware, that the AppleIISd does not use the FAT format like other SD or CF storage solutions does, it uses the ProDOS format directly. This means that you can not simply take a ProDOS image and drop it to the card in the Windows Explorer, it has to be written using CiderPress. 1. Open CiderPress in Admin mode (Right-click on Icon, "Open as Administrator"). 2. Select "Volume copier" from the icon bar or select "Tools -> Volume copier (open volume)" from the menu. 3. Make sure that "Open as read-only" is deselected. Select the SD card's logical volume from the list. Triple check  that you have selected the correct volume and don't come crying when your PC has only a ProDOS volume left to boot 😉 4. When you open an SD card for the first time like this it might show an MS-DOS volume with SD card's size. This gives you an opportunity to check  again! Select...
Read more

AppleIISd

Image
For the past few month I have been developing a storage solution for the Apple II that, to my knowledge, hasn't been done before. A SD card as a hard-drive replacement. It is nearly finished and has (hopefully) only minor issues left to fix. I admit, this doesn't sound neither groundbreaking, nor highly complex, but that is not the goal I am aiming for. I wanted to build something for the Apple II for quite some time, because that is what this computer was originally aimed at. It also gave me the chance to learn more about the hardware and internal parts of ProDOS. Finally I wanted to have a cheap mass storage, that may be assembled quite easily from parts that are not too complicated. Of course, there are already lots of devices that have an sd card and you can choose a floppy image like the or are feature stuffed, but i wanted it to be as simple as possible: ProDOS may access the card directly and boot support shall be provided. Luckily, I remembered André Fachat's  S...
Read more

IIgs breaktrough

Image
Last night I had a major breakthrough for my SD card interface! Not only does it work, it boots GS/OS on the Apple IIgs! 🎉 Switching the source code from Merlin-8 on the IIe to CC65 in Visual Studio and using an EEPROM sped up my development cycle quite a bit. This wasn't a fix for the issues, of course, but it helped. As usual, there were a lot of small things involved and I have learned some lessons. First lesson: the disk status function uses the X- and Y-registers as return values. However, when you load these registers with the return values and then insert a function call that does not only save these registers but uses them for slot addressing, it will crash. There simply isn't a slot number 255 in the Apple II 😉 Second lesson: SDHC cards use block addressing, not byte addressing. Some weeks ago, my 512 MB card died and I replaced it with an 8 GB card. I knew before that it was initialized correctly, so I assumed it worked as well. The problem was b...
Read more